women and the hijab
Saturday, April 05, 2008
One of the
blogs I read frequently is called Muslim
Matters. Todayís post was an article by Ruth Nasrullah who responds to the
question, ďWhy donít they dress like us? In other words, why donít American
Muslim women dress like other women in America?
Ms. Nasrullah says the question ďreeks of ignorance.Ē Actually, I think it is a
very good question, as was her answer (in spite of her defensiveness).
Ms. Nasrullah makes four main points. 1) Nuns wear head coverings which are
basically like a hijab (Muslim head covering) but we donít look down on them.
2) The virgin Mary is nearly always depicted as wearing a head covering so why
donít Christian women honor her by dressing like her. 3) Western women who
dress immodestly in public have to worry about what society thinks. Muslim
women only have to worry about what their husbands think. 4) Muslim women dress
like they do because they are following the mandates of their religion, which
takes real courage in Muslim-minority societies.
Ms. Nusrullah could have strengthened her case by mentioning that the Apostle
Paul commands modesty and tells women to wear head coverings (at least while
Frankly, as a Christian, I respect Muslim women in America who wear the hijab.
They always dress modestly and have the courage of their convictions.
On the other hand, from a Christian perspective, I suspect that Paulís commands
about head coverings are cultural rather than universal (Mennonite and Amish
women would disagree).
And I think Paulís commands about modesty apply to both men and women, but
those commands donít require one particular type of clothing. It is possible to
dress modestly and still wear contemporary, fashionable clothing (some
Muslim-American women would agree).
Unfortunately, the immodest dress exhibited by many Christians shows that they
are much more influenced by modern pop culture than they are by the Bible.
Would that Christians (men and women) had the same courage of convictions that
most Muslim women do.
Dennis at 9:42