Muslim jurists welcome UK chief justice's support for sharia role in mediation
LONDON - Leading Muslim jurists on Friday welcomed comments by Britain's chief justice supporting a role for Sharia law in resolving disputes.
Robert Barr, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Phillips, said in a speech on Thursday that there was no question of Islamic law replacing English law.
However, "there is no reason why Sharia principles, or any other religious code, should not be the basis for mediation or other forms of alternative dispute resolution."
Shaykh Faiz Siddiqi, a barrister and chairman of the governing council of the Muslim Arbitration Tribunal, said Friday that critics of any use of Islamic law failed to recognize that both parties had to agree to any form of dispute resolution in Britain.
Shamim Qureshi, the presiding judge of the Muslim Arbitration Tribunal, said the application of Sharia law could be useful in settling disputes about forced marriages, according to a statement released by the tribunal.
Qureshi, a judge in Wolverhampton Magistrates Court, is one of the few Muslims to serve as a judge in England.
The Muslim Arbitration Tribunal, established last year, offers alternative resolution of family disputes, forced marriages, and disputes over debts, commercial matters and inheritance.
In his speech at the East London Muslim Centre, Phillips said there is a widespread misunderstanding of Sharia law in Britain.
"Part of the misconception about Sharia law is the belief that Sharia is only about mandating sanctions such as flogging, stoning, the cutting off of hands, or death for those who fail to comply with the law," Phillips said.
"The view of many of Sharia law is coloured by violent extremists who invoke it, perversely, to justify terrorist atrocities such as suicide bombing, which I understand to be in conflict with Islamic principles," Phillips said.
He said British media, in particular, had misunderstood a speech in February by Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, who also supported a role for Sharia law, specifically suggesting a role in resolving disputes.
"A point that the archbishop was making was that it was possible for individuals voluntarily to conduct their lives in accordance with Sharia principles without this being in conflict with the rights guaranteed by our law," Phillips said.
He noted that it is already permissible in England for parties in a dispute to agree to resolve under rules other than English law.
Please report any
broken links to
Copyright © 1988-2012 irfi.org. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer